Editorial Review – The Rise and Fall of the Traditional Theories of Creation and Community the Next Emergence


Title: The Rise and Fall of the Traditional Theories of Creation and Community the Next Emergence

Author: David C. Shaw

Genre: Philosophical / Historical Non-fiction


The Rise and Fall of the Traditional Theories of Creation and Community the Next Emergence is an essay discussing the evolution of stories about the creation of man from ancient to modern times. The author, David C. Shaw, uses both the ancient Hebrew creation story from the Book of Genesis and ancient Greek creation theories to describe the history of creation as humans understand it today. He then moves on to discuss his theory that community is the next emergence, referencing, analyzing, and providing his thoughts on Harold Morowitz’s work titled, The Emergence of Everything: How the World Became Complex.

In his introduction, Shaw recognizes the significance of the topic of creation, stating that we can’t truly know who we are unless we know where we stand in relation to the act of creation.  He describes both the foundation and fall of the two main creation theories, Hebrew and Greek, both of which stated the heavens were a solid body. Shaw’s recounting of the theories of creation will engage readers with a love for history.

One topic in particular will prove interesting to those who enjoy philosophical and scientific theories. It is the difference between natural and supernatural revelation of the Hebrew creation story as knowledge of our scientific world has increased throughout time. Through natural revelation, Shaw argues that we must alter our creation story to match what we know is scientifically true about our world. Through supernatural revelation we must understand that the purpose of God’s creation story is to teach salvation, not science or philosophy, and that God does not put weight on the link between the creation story and the modern-day scientific universe. It is a new and enlightening take on a widely discussed topic in both religious and scientific communities.

Readers may also be intrigued by Shaw’s take on the evolution of humans’ belief in God. He argues that proof of the heavens as a solid vault, the foundation of both the Hebrew and Greek creation stories up until astrologer Edmund Halley proved it incorrect in 1718, was the main evidence that God existed. Modern understanding of the universe has required humans to shift away from scientific and physical evidence of God to the more intangible.

Although it may take a significant amount of brain power and concentration to grasp the more complex and illusive concepts in Shaw’s book, it is not due to Shaw’s writing but rather to the intangible nature of the subject matter. With a formal and academic writing style, this book will prove to be an enlightening challenge for readers. That being said, Shaw’s connection between the historical evolution of creation stories, the first topic discussed in his book, and his final conclusion that community is the next emergence could be clearer to avoid confusion. Toward the end, it was difficult to understand how the first series of topics supported his final theory.

Through exploration of the stories of creation, David Shaw’s essay will guide readers down an alternate path to answering the age-old question, “Who am I?” In his book, Shaw provides engaging historical recounts of the Hebrew and Greek creation stories and ties them to the idea of the heavens as a solid entity, an ancient but new concept for many readers. Shaw has created a logical, educational, and well-formulated essay to present his alternate theory of community as the next emergence.



This Editorial Review was written by the Book Review Directory staff. To receive a similarly honest, professional review for one of your own books, click here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.